TM Forums
Back to search

CryptoCurrency

#Post
1

Can crypto ie Bitcoin and like be bought and sold on trademe?
I could findn't a catagory on it so posted in Computers as that how its generated
Thanks

andywatts - 2021-01-06 16:51:00
2

This message was deleted.

kittycatkin - 2021-01-06 16:56:00
3

Why would anyone buy or sell it on Trademe, you can buy it elsewhere at market price, so you would lose out buying and selling where someone is taking a commission.

loud_37 - 2021-01-06 17:07:00
4

What goes up must come down and in the case of pretend money, it's really only legitimised wealth redistribution. If someone gains then someone looses.

tegretol - 2021-01-06 17:21:00
5

This message was deleted.

kittycatkin - 2021-01-06 18:53:00
6
kittycatkin wrote:

It may prove not to be pretend money, but I won't be risking my real money on the chance that it won't !

Well it really is pretend money as it is only backed/assured by a promise. In general, conventional currency is backed by good/services/assets. There is a huge difference.

tegretol - 2021-01-06 19:33:00
7
tegretol wrote:

Well it really is pretend money as it is only backed/assured by a promise. In general, conventional currency is backed by good/services/assets. There is a huge difference.

That's just rubbish, people pay stupid/good money for promises and other stuff written on silly little bits of paper or stored in digital systems every day... Insurance for one...
I have real money from selling half a coin sitting in a bank right now that says it is not pretend money at all...

Edited by king1 at 8:16 pm, Wed 6 Jan

king1 - 2021-01-06 20:14:00
8
andywatts wrote:

Can crypto ie Bitcoin and like be bought and sold on trademe?
I could findn't a catagory on it so posted in Computers as that how its generated
Thanks

to answer your question, No - crypto comes under financial reporting requirements, KYC etc so there is the usual rubbish of opening account, providing ID etc required.

you have a couple of options though like easycrypto and localbitcoin, the latter used to be a free market with no ID required etc not sure if still the case

Edited by king1 at 8:23 pm, Wed 6 Jan

king1 - 2021-01-06 20:20:00
9
tegretol wrote:

Well it really is pretend money as it is only backed/assured by a promise. In general, conventional currency is backed by good/services/assets. There is a huge difference.

Conventional currency is just a promissory note, its not backed by anything but faith in it.

loud_37 - 2021-01-06 20:39:00
10
king1 wrote:

to answer your question, No - crypto comes under financial reporting requirements, KYC etc so there is the usual rubbish of opening account, providing ID etc required.

you have a couple of options though like easycrypto and localbitcoin, the latter used to be a free market with no ID required etc not sure if still the case


Thanks for the reply
I use localcryptos.com but was just wondering.
Amazingly out of all these replies only you gave a credible answer.
Cheers

Edited by andywatts at 10:16 pm, Wed 6 Jan

andywatts - 2021-01-06 22:15:00
11
andywatts wrote:


Thanks for the reply
I use localcryptos.com but was just wondering.
Amazingly out of all these replies only you gave a credible answer.
Cheers

Use easycrypto.ai. good nz company to deal with.

mss2006 - 2021-01-07 16:37:00
12
tegretol wrote:

Well it really is pretend money as it is only backed/assured by a promise. In general, conventional currency is backed by good/services/assets. There is a huge difference.

Cute. You think the money in your bank account is backed by something.

sw20 - 2021-01-07 16:41:00
13
sw20 wrote:

Cute. You think the money in your bank account is backed by something.

It's certainly backed by far more assurance than cryptocurrency!!!

tegretol - 2021-01-08 10:34:00
14

its real enough for IRD
https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/427113/ird-to-begin-prob
ing-crypto-currency-investors

bitsnpieces2020 - 2021-01-08 13:31:00
15
tegretol wrote:

It's certainly backed by far more assurance than cryptocurrency!!!

It's backed by faith. That is it.

If your bank fails, your money is gone. There is no insurance.

Edited by sw20 at 1:48 pm, Fri 8 Jan

sw20 - 2021-01-08 13:48:00
16
sw20 wrote:

It's backed by faith. That is it.

If your bank fails, your money is gone. There is no insurance.

unless its kiwibank then i think the govt would have to back them. if banks failed the whole country would collapse so maybe safer than invented currency

ascotbks - 2021-01-08 15:39:00
17
sw20 wrote:

It's backed by faith. That is it.

If your bank fails, your money is gone. There is no insurance.

The 5 main banks in NZ are basically "too big to fail" ... there maybe no "formal" insurance or government backing in place, but if any of the big 5 got into really "financial poo" the governments of Australia and/or New Zealand would step in and shore things up.. depositors may only get their principal back up to a limit, but the limit would be at such a level that your "average mom & pop" invester would not be completely ruined.. I think the same would happen with the kiwisaver funds... the government has invested too much time / money & effort into getting the scheme up and running and accepted, to have some "rouge" fund undo all their efforts and put a halt to the up take !!

onl_148 - 2021-01-08 15:56:00
18

I thought the govt had stopped contributing to kiwi-saver now they had everyone hooked in..?

mechnificent - 2021-01-08 16:59:00
19
mechnificent wrote:

I thought the govt had stopped contributing to kiwi-saver now they had everyone hooked in..?

Tax credits of $521.43 per year continue for every investor provided they deposit $1042.86 each year. If you only deposit the minimum that's a 50% return year on year. Best investment in town.

Edited by sw20 at 5:18 pm, Fri 8 Jan

sw20 - 2021-01-08 17:13:00
20
onl_148 wrote:

The 5 main banks in NZ are basically "too big to fail" ... there maybe no "formal" insurance or government backing in place, but if any of the big 5 got into really "financial poo" the governments of Australia and/or New Zealand would step in and shore things up.. depositors may only get their principal back up to a limit, but the limit would be at such a level that your "average mom & pop" invester would not be completely ruined.. I think the same would happen with the kiwisaver funds... the government has invested too much time / money & effort into getting the scheme up and running and accepted, to have some "rouge" fund undo all their efforts and put a halt to the up take !!

still an awful lot of faith in there...

king1 - 2021-01-08 17:14:00
21
onl_148 wrote:

The 5 main banks in NZ are basically "too big to fail" ... there maybe no "formal" insurance or government backing in place, but if any of the big 5 got into really "financial poo" the governments of Australia and/or New Zealand would step in and shore things up.. depositors may only get their principal back up to a limit, but the limit would be at such a level that your "average mom & pop" invester would not be completely ruined.. I think the same would happen with the kiwisaver funds... the government has invested too much time / money & effort into getting the scheme up and running and accepted, to have some "rouge" fund undo all their efforts and put a halt to the up take !!

NZ doesn't have the credit to bail out a bank anymore, that was all spent last year. Especially one owned by Aussie corporates. Quickest way to get voted out.

sw20 - 2021-01-08 17:17:00
22

quicker way would be to allow banks to fail and nz economy with them. nz dosent need credit just an electronic printing press

ascotbks - 2021-01-08 17:28:00
23

Why should someone bail out a badly run business, this is what is wrong with the world, there are so many zombie companies out there because the banks keep lending them money cause they no they will get bailed out.

loud_37 - 2021-01-08 18:08:00
24
tegretol wrote:

Well it really is pretend money as it is only backed/assured by a promise. In general, conventional currency is backed by good/services/assets. There is a huge difference.

What is the difference to the pieces of paper and metal disks in your pocket again? Or the number on a screen at your bank?

Do you think they are any less "pretend" ..really..

ronaldo8 - 2021-01-08 20:05:00
25

Forget about bail outs. Be more concerned about bail ins. Applies here in nz and many countries as well.

mss2006 - 2021-01-08 20:08:00
26

This message was deleted.

kittycatkin - 2021-01-08 20:13:00
27

This message was deleted.

kittycatkin - 2021-01-08 20:14:00
28

This message was deleted.

kittycatkin - 2021-01-08 20:16:00
29
kittycatkin wrote:

That happened in the past when banks were privately owned, it's highly unlikely to happen now. This is not the 1920s or 30s.

BNZ were days away from collapse in 1990. The government had to bail them out, that won't happen today. Too much money involved.

sw20 - 2021-01-08 20:22:00
30

most business in nz was close to collapse in 1990 after world wide share market crash in 1987 but didnt and govt would bail big business out like it did then
good info here
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_Monday_(1987)

ascotbks - 2021-01-08 21:04:00
31

Don't forget about bail-in, the opposite of a bailout, which involves the rescue of a bank by governments using deposits for funding.

https://www.rbnz.govt.nz/-/media/ReserveBank/Files/regulatio
n-and-supervision/banks/policy/OBR%20Made%20Simple%20WEB.pdf
?revision=339f2903-b98e-4b6f-888f-33389d2adda9

mopeds - 2021-01-08 21:22:00
32
ronaldo8 wrote:

What is the difference to the pieces of paper and metal disks in your pocket again? Or the number on a screen at your bank?

Do you think they are any less "pretend" ..really..

You obviously have no knowledge of fiscal matters if you really do think that to be the case.

tegretol - 2021-01-08 21:54:00
33
tegretol wrote:

You obviously have no knowledge of fiscal matters if you really do think that to be the case.

Do you? The currency we use is not money, it’s backed by nothing and can be worthless at any stage, I don’t think it will come to this but it could happen.

loud_37 - 2021-01-08 22:45:00
34

The member deleted this message.

mss2006 - 2021-01-08 23:08:00
35
kittycatkin wrote:

Yes, but you had to sell the 'coin' to get the real money.

yep, that's usually how it works...

king1 - 2021-01-08 23:14:00
36
loud_37 wrote:

Do you? The currency we use is not money, it’s backed by nothing and can be worthless at any stage, I don’t think it will come to this but it could happen.

Correct.. there is a reason our and most all other modern currencies are called "fiat currencies". Google it. The debasement of asset backed currency started in 1971 with Nixoin putting an end to the Bretonwoods (sp) gold backed standard.

Modern money has only the value that we all agree it has. Furthermore our fiat money is continually being diluted of its value through inflation by continues printing if of monetary nothingness. Ie how many trillions did the usa print last year out of nothing? 20% of their total ever cash ever created?

mss2006 - 2021-01-08 23:26:00
37
mss2006 wrote:

.......Modern money has only the value that we all agree it has. Furthermore our fiat money is continually being diluted of its value through inflation by continues printing if of monetary nothingness......

The key word is 'we' which means 100% of society. I wonder what % of society has the same agreement about cryptocurrency. !!

Printing money is not a problem as long as the amount printed does not exceed the increased gdp in any one year. Any more creates inflation, any less creates deflation. It's the most elegant way of managing the value of domestic currency.

tegretol - 2021-01-09 11:03:00
38
tegretol wrote:

The key word is 'we' which means 100% of society. I wonder what % of society has the same agreement about cryptocurrency. !!

I kind of think the percentage argument is irrelevant - anything has value *if* there is someone prepared to pay for it - any asset or commodity is only going to have value to the subset of society that value it...
Fiat money only has value because it is government sanctioned and legal tender, because of that it is more generally accepted, but that's about it...

king1 - 2021-01-09 11:25:00
39

One question that has yet to be answered on this one - if there are such huge gains to be made by holdered of CC then who are the loosers? Real wealth can't just be created by inventing a new form of money and few people seem to be able to explain who the loosers are....

tegretol - 2021-01-10 10:26:00
40
tegretol wrote:

One question that has yet to be answered on this one - if there are such huge gains to be made by holdered of CC then who are the loosers? Real wealth can't just be created by inventing a new form of money and few people seem to be able to explain who the loosers are....

I don't get why you think there has to be losers... crypto is really no different to any other kind of market...

coins are created initially, by mining or otherwise, hardware and power costs involved etc - this is not *free* money - costs were incurred to obtain it, decisions made to hold or sell at times that may or may not be fortuitous.

When selling, a buyer and seller agree on a price, the buyer usually hoping the price will go up and a capital gain obtained, the seller looking to cash out for their own reasons, normal laws of supply and demand apply, no losers here

it behaves no different to share markets, remember the headlines about billions of dollars being wiped off eg
https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/money/2020/03/anz-economist-s
-stark-warning-after-billions-of-dollars-wiped-off-stock-mar
ket.html

No different with crypto markets, if there are any losers it is simply those left holding when the market crashes, but as with other markets there are the usual strategies to mitigate the risk. ie don't sell after a crash otherwise you lock in the loss, buy low sell high etc

Edited by king1 at 11:35 am, Sun 10 Jan

king1 - 2021-01-10 11:29:00
41
king1 wrote:

I don't get why you think there has to be losers...
No different with crypto markets, if there are any losers it is simply those left holding when the market crashes,................

I rest my case.

Nothing's for nothing and for every winner there is a looser.!!

tegretol - 2021-01-10 12:16:00
42

Actually there is a difference. Stocks or Shares are in actual companies which are actually producing something.

For example you could buy stocks in "Mr Chips" Mr Chips produces hot chips which are bought by restaurants, cafes, takeaway outfits etc.
https://www.mrchips.co.nz/

Chip are always popular, I mean everyone loves chips right? So this would likely be a stable company to buy stocks in.

Heading south you have Makikihi Fries, https://makikihifries.co.nz/ who are producing chips near Waimate.

These are only two examples, and there are many other companies producing other things.

CryptoCurrency is producing nothing.

tygertung - 2021-01-10 12:23:00
43
tegretol wrote:

I rest my case.

Nothing's for nothing and for every winner there is a looser.!!

well it's the standard supply and demand economics you find in any market, but if you want to take that as a win, it's all yours...

king1 - 2021-01-10 12:43:00
44
tygertung wrote:


CryptoCurrency is producing nothing.

neither does fiat - that's why it's a currency, it's not supposed to...

like fiat money it is a store of value, unit of account, and medium of exchange yada yada
like fiat money it's value goes up and down
unlike usual fiat money its value is much more volatile...

Edited by king1 at 12:55 pm, Sun 10 Jan

king1 - 2021-01-10 12:45:00
45
king1 wrote:

well it's the standard supply and demand economics you find in any market, but if you want to take that as a win, it's all yours...

Legitimised gambling with no useful product being produced then!

tegretol - 2021-01-10 12:45:00
46
tygertung wrote:

Actually there is a difference. Stocks or Shares are in actual companies which are actually producing something.

For example you could buy stocks in "Mr Chips" Mr Chips produces hot chips which are bought by restaurants, cafes, takeaway outfits etc.
https://www.mrchips.co.nz/

Chip are always popular, I mean everyone loves chips right? So this would likely be a stable company to buy stocks in.

Heading south you have Makikihi Fries, https://makikihifries.co.nz/ who are producing chips near Waimate.

These are only two examples, and there are many other companies producing other things.

CryptoCurrency is producing nothing.

You've got it.

tegretol - 2021-01-10 12:46:00
47
tegretol wrote:

Legitimised gambling with no useful product being produced then!

i'm surprised, so much ignorance in such a few words...

king1 - 2021-01-10 12:53:00
48
tegretol wrote:

What goes up must come down and in the case of pretend money,

US Treasury does not see it as pretend money...

https://www.theregister.com/2021/01/06/digital_currency_us/

tony9 - 2021-01-10 17:17:00
49
king1 wrote:

i'm surprised, so much ignorance in such a few words...

Really? Your insult belies your ignorance of my knowledge base!!!

tegretol - 2021-01-10 18:12:00
50
king1 wrote:

neither does fiat - that's why it's a currency, it's not supposed to...

like fiat money it is a store of value, unit of account, and medium of exchange yada yada
like fiat money it's value goes up and down
unlike usual fiat money its value is much more volatile...

Yes, but you compared CryptoCurrency to the Share or Stock Market.

tygertung - 2021-01-10 18:50:00
Free Web Hosting