TM Forums
Back to search

best flour for cakes

#Post
1

What makes a cake moist? I'm working on my best cake by experimenting and tweaking. Never found a banana cake like the ones I had 20 yrs ago.

artangel - 2019-03-28 14:29:00
2

Don't skimp on the butter and don't overcook.

davidt4 - 2019-03-28 15:18:00
3

Liquids.
So milk, butter and so on.
Adjust your proportions

lythande1 - 2019-03-28 15:35:00
4

The question header was "flour", but that's not the most important factor in making a cake moist, as others have already said.

But regarding flour for cakes - use either SR (self raising) flour, or plain flour with raising agents of your choice. HG (high grade) flour is probably best used for breads and other yeast-based bakery goods (though can be used if no other). Gluten-free flours each have their own specific issues, and one either follows a recipe, or experiments with standard recipes.

autumnwinds - 2019-03-28 15:43:00
5
artangel wrote:

What makes a cake moist? I'm working on my best cake by experimenting and tweaking. Never found a banana cake like the ones I had 20 yrs ago.

Probably more than 20 years ago now we only had one choice of flour. It didn't even come with the handle "all purpose". However, despite that lack, I baked everything with it and everything came out perfectly. Now I spend at least 10mins before any baking event going through my instruction book to ensure I am using the right flour for the job. It is so annoying that recipes do not bother to specify which type of flour to use.

buzzy110 - 2019-03-28 16:34:00
6
buzzy110 wrote:

Probably more than 20 years ago now we only had one choice of flour. It didn't even come with the handle "all purpose". However, despite that lack, I baked everything with it and everything came out perfectly.

I so agree with you!
(Though more like 40-50 years ago...)

I remember the old farmhouse kitchen, with the "new" innovation - pull-down bins for the flour, which came in big sacks of a coarse whitish material, usually made into underwear or shirts, after the logo was washed out!

And flour sifters were an absolute necessity - not just to "fluff up" the flour, but to remove the "visitors" (weevils) that often came with the sack....

Edited by autumnwinds at 4:39 pm, Thu 28 Mar

autumnwinds - 2019-03-28 16:38:00
7

So now that we are discussing the best flour to use, I am still at a loss to decide which flour is best for scones when not using self-raising flour which I never, never, never use because it makes everything taste blurrgh.

buzzy110 - 2019-03-28 16:53:00
8

I use High Grade for everything and I haven't had a failure yet. Personally I don't think it really matters.

cgvl - 2019-03-28 17:02:00
9

As I understand it, HG (high grade) has more gluten than plain flour.... but it appears it's the protein content, which may also still be the gluten part. Certainly, I wouldn't make bread or yeast products without using HG flour

This is one site's comment:
**High grade or “strong” flour. Also called Baker's Flour is made from semi-hard wheat and has a medium to high protein content. It is used for making bread. ... Standard or plain flour, also called soft flour, is made from soft wheat varieties and has a low protein content.**

https://www.bakeinfo.co.nz/School-Zone/Baking-Basics/Flour-T
ypes

autumnwinds - 2019-03-28 17:36:00
10

There is no best flour for cakes, but there are best recipes. Trial and error really.

rainrain1 - 2019-03-28 18:46:00
11

Thanks all for your comments. I used high grade on my first 2 trials and was ok but not ideal. Using a benchtop oven az that's all I have.

Did my own research and found cake flour has 7-9% protein. Plain flour has approx 10%. To make cake flour is 2 tsp of corn starch to one cup flour.

Will be trialling different sugars as well. Trial one was 200g raw sugar - too sweet. Trial 2 I reduced by 15% to 170g. Turned out a bit dry but it could've been from overcooming. Will use castor sugar today.

Anyone try using yolks only?

artangel - 2019-03-29 03:42:00
Free Web Hosting