TM Forums
Back to search

4 egg sponge

#Post
1

Is 4 eggs enough for a lovely soft sponge.
Made one the other day, followed the recipe to a T.
When folding in the sifted SR flour it went all lumpy.
After it was cooked and sliced, it was kinda heavy and cakey.
Get what I mean.
It was demolished quickly, and rose very high, but not soft and fluffy.
Any ideas why?

korbo - 2018-08-08 21:21:00
2

I find mine does that if I don't beat the eggs and sugar long enough. Beat until very pale and thick - takes about 4 minutes to add the sugar a few tablespoons at a time and get it to this stage

bisloy - 2018-08-08 22:14:00
3

4 eggs is fine. I never use SR flour always use plain flour and baking powder and especially cornflour (this adds lightness to the mix). The eggs must be beaten very well and the sugar added a tsp at a time until combined. Fold in the flour lightly making sure not to beat the mixture so the eggs don't collapse. Carefully fold the flour in with a spatula until all the flour is combined. Good Luck

nanee2jlp - 2018-08-08 22:22:00
4

the recipe said to beat egg whites stiff, then STIR in yolks. obviously it meant beat. will try another day.

korbo - 2018-08-09 19:21:00
5

A friend of mine has never had success with a light and fluffy sponge until she tried Jo Seagers recipe

http://www.joseagar.co.nz/component/yoorecipe/recipe/6-spong
e-cake

sarahb5 - 2018-08-09 20:42:00
6
korbo wrote:

the recipe said to beat egg whites stiff, then STIR in yolks. obviously it meant beat. will try another day.


I beat egg whites till stiff and then beat in egg yolks one at a time

Edited by nanee2jlp at 8:53 pm, Thu 9 Aug

nanee2jlp - 2018-08-09 20:53:00
7

Have a very old light recipe for 4 egg sponge that rises extra high, All our kids love it with jelly in the middle. If youd like it yell out.

fifie - 2018-08-10 12:58:00
8

yes please I would

nanee2jlp - 2018-08-10 13:05:00
9

Old recipe of jelly Sponge.
You need a electric mixer for this, in old measurments sorry.
Pre heat oven to 190c. Grease and paper 2 round sponge sandwich tins putting lightly oiled paper well up sides of tins (about 3 inches high) as these sponges rise up higher than the normal ones do.
4 eggs, room temperature.
6 oz sugar
4 oz cornflour
2 oz flour
1 heaped teaspoon baking powder
Pinch salt
2 tablespoon water.
Seperate yolks from whites, beat egg whites and salt till stiff. Add sugar and water gradually at boiling point, (put in saucepan and bring to boil stirring so it dosent burn, then pour slowly into whites as they are beating.Add egg yolks, beat all well till nice and fluffy. Carefully fold in sifted dry ingredients. Put mixture into 2 tins and bake about 15 minutes middle of the oven, till well risen and cooked (don’t keep opening oven door lets heat out they will not rise).
Cool few minutes, take out of tins.Make jelly.
1 packet jelly crystals. Strawberry or raspberry is nice.
2 cups near boiling water
Make jelly stir well to dissolve put in fridge till its only about ½ to 3/4 set.
Meantime put 1 half of sponge on a plate take a long strip of grease proof paper about 4 inches in width place round the half on plate, pull it firm and put 2 pins in the paper 1 top 1 bottom, so it will hold the jelly in.
Pour ½ the wobbly jelly in carefully spread over sponge, then take top half of sponge carefully sit it on top of the jelly inside the paper. Sit in fridge to finish setting when ready to serve, un pin paper carefully pull paper off running a knife round to neaten any jelly on edge, dust top with icing sugar.. Cut into wedges from centre to serve.
Sometimes ive used only one sponge sliced in half, filled with cream and fruit, and frozen the other half.

fifie - 2018-08-11 11:07:00
10

Thank you fifie - made the sponge and it was great - that recipe is a keeper for sure

nanee2jlp - 2018-08-12 15:20:00
11
sarahb5 wrote:

A friend of mine has never had success with a light and fluffy sponge until she tried Jo Seagers recipe

http://www.joseagar.co.nz/component/yoorecipe/recipe/6-spong
e-cake

Holy moley - she must have had a few glasses of wine when she typed that out..........

Seriously though - I have never made a sponge and have a hankering for one for some reason. I will attempt to follow the recipe provided.

awoftam - 2019-06-25 18:04:00
12
awoftam wrote:

Holy moley - she must have had a few glasses of wine when she typed that out..........

Seriously though - I have never made a sponge and have a hankering for one for some reason. I will attempt to follow the recipe provided.

LOL!!
You could well be right (about the wine!)

I think I'll try the recipe, too, though

autumnwinds - 2019-06-25 22:37:00
13
korbo wrote:

the recipe said to beat egg whites stiff, then STIR in yolks. obviously it meant beat. will try another day.

I beat the egg whites till when the beater is removed the white in it comes away with it. I also place the egg yolks into an appropriate sized metal bowl, place in another bowl of hot water, and beat them till they are pale, creamy and have almost doubled in volume. THEN I gently stir them together.

I just thought that was the only way to do it no matter what instruction is missing from the recipe.

But no matter what, I have only made one sponge using that method. It came out beautiful and light and airy but it was also slightly 'chewy' and required a 'sharp-as' knife to slice without squashing.

If I was going to bake sponges I would find a traditional Victoria sponge. It has a different texture which I think I would prefer.

buzzy110 - 2019-06-26 10:28:00
14

Use room temperature eggs.

tutifruiti - 2019-06-28 18:13:00
15
buzzy110 wrote:

I beat the egg whites till when the beater is removed the white in it comes away with it. I also place the egg yolks into an appropriate sized metal bowl, place in another bowl of hot water, and beat them till they are pale, creamy and have almost doubled in volume. THEN I gently stir them together.

I just thought that was the only way to do it no matter what instruction is missing from the recipe.

But no matter what, I have only made one sponge using that method. It came out beautiful and light and airy but it was also slightly 'chewy' and required a 'sharp-as' knife to slice without squashing.

If I was going to bake sponges I would find a traditional Victoria sponge. It has a different texture which I think I would prefer.

But a Victoria sandwich isn't a sponge because it has fat in it - a sponge is just flour, eggs and sugar

sarahb5 - 2019-06-28 22:43:00
16

This is the recipe I use. I have tried many and all but this one has failed, even the Fielders recipe has not gone well.

Easy Sponge

4 eggs
6 oz / 175grmsCornflour
6 oz / 175grmsSugar
Heaped teaspoon Baking powder
2 Tablespoons Boiling water.

Using a cake mixer is the easiest way to make this.

Separate Eggs.

Beat whites till stiff.

Add sugar and water mixing in.
Add yolks and fold the dry ingredients.

Bake in two 9inch cake tins. greased and bottoms lined.

Bake 350 F / 180C for 20 mins.

When you remove from oven, drop from knee height square onto floor, this 'shocks' the sponge and it won't sink when cooled. Cool on a cake rack.

NB don't try making these in sponge tins cos they will over flow.once filled this makes a huge deep sponge.

You can use any fruit for the center that you like, I

Quote
madj (587 587 positive feedback) 11:02 am, Wed 23 Ma

bev00 - 2019-07-08 21:51:00
Free Web Hosting